3 hours ago
3
ARTICLE AD BOX
NEW DELHI: In a determination that could person a salutary bearing connected the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), Supreme Court connected Friday reversed its eyebrow-raising May 2 verdict, directing liquidation of bankrupt Bhushan Power and Steel Limited, to enactment backmost successful spot the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal's Feb 2020 determination to let Sajjan-Jindal-led JSW Steel revive the failed entity.A seat of Chief Justice B R Gavai and Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and K Vinod Chandran reversed the determination of a two-judge seat led by Justice Bela M Trivedi, since retired, accepting arguments of solicitor wide Tushar Mehta, who appeared for the Committee of Creditors, and elder advocator Neeraj Kishan Kaul for JSW, which invested Rs 20,000 crore to revive BPSL and marque it a profit-making company.Clock can't beryllium enactment backmost to penalise JSW, says Supreme Court The two-judge Supreme Court seat had rejected the Committee of Creditors-approved solution program of JSW, which was concurrently recovered to beryllium dependable by some National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) and NCLAT.
Using exclusive powers nether Article 142 of the Constitution, SC had directed NCLT to initiate liquidation proceedings of BPSL portion deciding an entreaty by 1 of the promoters of BPSL challenging the solution plan.Writing the 136-page judgement connected cognition of assorted IBC provisions, CJI Gavai said, "The legislature purposefully did not see a means to situation the commercialized contented exercised by the CoC.
This makes a situation to the aforesaid non-justiciable... Any interference successful the paramount nonsubjective of the CoC of exercising its commercialized contented would magnitude to the tribunal rewriting the instrumentality and going against the precise objectives of the IBC.
" Referring to takeover of BPSL by JSW, the CJI-led seat said that since the IBC's nonsubjective of ensuring firm debtor continues arsenic a going interest has been achieved and loss-making BPSL has been transformed to a profit-making entity, the timepiece cannot beryllium enactment backmost to penalise JSW by ordering BPSL's liquidation.
"This volition decision the precise intent of IBC to confer sanctity to the finality of duly approved solution plan," SC said.The tribunal rejected the COC's late-in-the-day statement for organisation of net earlier interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA) amongst creditors. SC said since the petition for solution program (RfRP) issued by the solution nonrecreational for the firm insolvency solution process did not supply for organisation of EBITDA among creditors, the COC cannot request it now.SC said sans a circumstantial proviso successful RfRP regarding organisation of EBITDA, it is impermissible for CoC to rise specified a plea 5 years aft support of the solution plan. "A palmy solution applicant (JSW successful this case) cannot beryllium faced with undecided claims aft its solution program has been accepted. That would magnitude to 'hydra heads popping up' which would propulsion into uncertainty the amounts payable by a prospective solution applicant who would instrumentality implicit the concern of the firm debtor," it said. RBI, successful 2017, had issued a circular identifying 12 large-scale firm defaulters, with outstanding debts valued astatine Rs 5,000 crore and above, infamously known arsenic the "dirty dozen",which included BPSL.
